OPENING STATEMENT
In the latest attempt to fix a self-made problem, the SEC now plans to fine schools that exceed the House settlement's revenue-sharing cap. It raises plenty of questions, and two matter most: 1) will it slow spending, and 2) where does the fine money go? The second carries extra weight because the schools being fined are the same ones writing the rules. The perceived conflict is striking.
Called "Plan B" the proposal is the fallback if the Protect College Sports Act dies in Congress, which looks more likely by the week. While administrators are still debating the numbers, fines would start below 1% of the overage and climb to 10% on spending above $70.5 million. The idea is also spreading beyond the SEC, with the Big Ten, ACC and Big 12 reportedly coalescing around it. One athletic director told Yahoo Sports that the richest schools will just pay the fine.
Pro leagues already tax overspending, and MLB and the NBA each do it differently. In both, the tax sits inside a collectively bargained agreement. The union negotiated the threshold, and the money stays in the system, including player benefits. You can argue with the formula, but the players helped write it.
The college sports world has no equivalent. Reports say the money could go to the House plaintiffs' attorneys, the College Sports Commission, or a post-graduate medical fund. Each has a problem:
College Sports Commission: The enforcer would be funded by the overspending that it polices, so it gains financially every time a school breaks the cap.
Plaintiffs' attorneys: Kessler and Berman have said they doubt the cap is legal without their approval. If they're paid from the fines, their approval becomes hard to take at face value.
Medical fund: It sounds generous. But the money would come from pay that athletes were barred from earning, and they had no say in the arrangement.
Strip away the branding and this proposal looks more like competitors agreeing on a ceiling for labor costs than collecting a toll from anyone who breaks it. If the richest schools just pay, only the schools that can't afford the fine are truly capped. Whether that holds up under antitrust scrutiny without athlete consent is a fair question for the lawyers.
The price of that toll matters, because schools already pay to get around the cap. Jamie Pollard, former Iowa State athletic director, told the Knight Commission this week that "our industry right now is laundering money." Leaving the job makes that easier to say, but he described a real practice: schools paying up to 20% to middlemen to move money through the system. If a 10% fine is cheaper, it works less like a deterrent and more like a discount for using the front door.
The same habit of spending ahead of the money runs through Pollard's second warning, which got less attention. Schools are borrowing against future media-rights revenue. If the bet comes up short, someone covers the difference. Athletic departments rarely absorb it themselves, and athletes are the most likely to feel it, through trimmed revenue-share payments, cut programs, or some other cost no one has named yet. They didn't make the projections or sign the loans, but they're first in line for the bill.
Keep the following in mind:
The Government Accountability Office found 94% of Division I athletic programs spent more than they generated in 2023-24, with a median gap of $20.6 million.
Florida State reported about $437 million in athletics-related debt, up roughly $200 million in a year.
Washington is projected to run a $16 million cash-flow deficit, with loans tied to future Big Ten money.
None of those figures says a collapse is coming. They do say many departments have little cushion if projections miss.
So if the money falls short, who gets paid first? Do revenue-share contracts rank ahead of bondholders and coaches' buyouts, or behind them? Are they guaranteed for their full term, or can a department in a cash crunch defer them? Athletes will likely hear the answer last.
There is a common thread in all of this. The cap limits what athletes earn when revenue is strong. The debt threatens what they receive when revenue is weak. In both cases, schools and conferences define the risk, price it, and keep the proceeds, and athletes carry the exposure.
A school that overspends to win, borrows against projections, and pays a fine to a body it helps fund has made every decision for athletes and none with them. That structure rewards control over stability, and it holds together only as long as the projections do.
Pro leagues handled this with bargaining, transparency about penalty money, and guaranteed contracts. Athletes can ask for the same three things now: a seat in setting the cap, a public accounting of where fines go, and a clear place in line when the money runs short.
EXHIBIT A
It does not appear that the House will be riding to the PCSA rescue. House Majority Leader Steve Scalise is among a group saying they will try to bring a version of the Protect College Sports Act to the floor the first week of December, while admitting that the bill "in its current form faces real challenges in the House," from Republican factions and Democrats who oppose it outright. They want narrow changes to hold "fragile coalitions" together. That is a tall order, even with Ted Cruz pushing. The bill must pass before the new Congress is sworn in on January 3, or it starts over. How many Republicans will actually be there to vote in December? What is clear, though, is that athletes are not part of writing those amendments.
EXHIBIT B
Last week we examined the proposed TEAM USA Act and its possible impact on international students. So interesting to note the data that came out this week. The Institute of International Education reports new international enrollment fell 18% in 2025-26, and fall 2026 shows another 15% drop. Excluding graduates on post-degree work authorization, who pay no tuition, enrollment fell about 8%. That is roughly 73,000 fewer paying students. NAFSA estimates the loss at $2.4 billion and 31,000 jobs. It represents another example of the major financial obstacles facing higher education.
ON THE DOCKET
Is LSU's eligibility saga over, or will this be the pattern? Wednesday night, RJ Luis played for the Tigers under a court order. By Thursday, president Wade Rousse had told coach Will Wade not to play him, and Luis's attorney said he will stand down. It's the second time LSU won in court, then retreated: Lane Kiffin never rostered two former NFL players a judge had cleared. The SEC's federal suit remains pending, so no court has ruled on whether a conference can override a state judge by threatening expulsion. Until one does, expect the next LSU athlete with an injunction to face the same choice.
FOOTNOTES
FOOTNOTE
“We’ll have an amazing porch and no house behind it.”
Penn State President Neeli Bendapudi on her concerns about athletics overshadowing academics.